Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

The place to describe any bugs you find in the software
Campbell
Site Admin
Posts: 589
Joined: Sun 14 Jul, 2024 10:21 am
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by Campbell »

I will add a Check Version link.

I'm not sure I understand about the merging payees though. If you merge two payees, it should keep one name, and add the other as an alias of the one that is kept. Are you not seeing this?
maxim-money-dl97
Posts: 64
Joined: Wed 14 Oct, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by maxim-money-dl97 »

Correct. To reproduce:
Ctrl+mouse-click to multiple-select 2+ payees, right-click any highlighted payee, and select Merge Payees
- The merged payee only keeps Alias(es) from 1 of the merged payees

These are related issues (let me know if you'd prefer a new post?):
- Sometimes Merge Payee prompts for merged payee name ; other times it doesn't (not sure why it won't when it doesn't)
- It seems to prompt for merged payee name when ALL merged payees were newly-created (i.e. none were imported and none have transactions)
- If ANY payee(s) being merged was imported from MSMoney, it typically won't prompt for merged payee name and sets merged payee as the imported one
- If 2+ payees being merged were imported from MSMoney, the resulting payee name typically isn't prompted for, so am unsure how the merged payee name was selected by the system
- Payees that have white-text (with matching transactions) vs being greyed-out (no matching transactions) may be a factor, ref screenshot:
image.png
image.png (1.78 KiB) Viewed 3122 times
-----
- When Merge Payee does prompt for merged payee name, clicking Cancel clears the payee name in payee list:
image.png
image.png (2.07 KiB) Viewed 3122 times
The merged payee name does initially appear in Payee Details > Details tab, but subsequently clicking on different payee, and then clicking the blank payee name (in payee list) results in blank fields under Payee Details > Details tab:
image.png
image.png (4.55 KiB) Viewed 3122 times
- Adding new Payee (via right-click) doesn't prompt to enter payee name ; it just creates one named "New Payee", "New Payee 1", etc
- Creating new Payee also auto-creates Alias of "New Payee", "New Payee 1", etc, that must be deleted (if unwanted, which is likely always)

- Deleting Payee via right-click does not offer confirmation prompt (Using Delete key DOES prompt for confirmation)
- Deleting Alias via right-click does not offer confirmation prompt (Using Delete key DOES prompt for confirmation)

- If Search box contains a search string, and a new payee is created that matches that entered search string, the new payee doesn't appear until search string is modified (to continue matching the new payee)

- If a payee is selected in Payees list, and then same payee is clicked again, it highlights the name to allow editing ; while in that state, right-clicking the payee > Delete doesn't do anything
- Also (with payee name highlighted to be renamed), right-clicking the payee > Find All Transactions loads an empty list

- While a payee is selected in Payees list, typing a letter doesn't shift focus to the first payee that starts with the typed letter ; this is VERY handy in MSMoney

IMHO the Payee view needs extended attention when possible.
Campbell
Site Admin
Posts: 589
Joined: Sun 14 Jul, 2024 10:21 am
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by Campbell »

maxim-money-dl97 wrote: Mon 02 Nov, 2026 4:46 am Ctrl+mouse-click to multiple-select 2+ payees, right-click any highlighted payee, and select Merge Payees
- The merged payee only keeps Alias(es) from 1 of the merged payees
This will be fixed in the next release.
- Sometimes Merge Payee prompts for merged payee name ; other times it doesn't (not sure why it won't when it doesn't)
- It seems to prompt for merged payee name when ALL merged payees were newly-created (i.e. none were imported and none have transactions)
- If ANY payee(s) being merged was imported from MSMoney, it typically won't prompt for merged payee name and sets merged payee as the imported one
- If 2+ payees being merged were imported from MSMoney, the resulting payee name typically isn't prompted for, so am unsure how the merged payee name was selected by the system
- Payees that have white-text (with matching transactions) vs being greyed-out (no matching transactions) may be a factor
I have improved the logic for merging. It now uses the number of transactions used by the payee to determine which is more important. If it is clear-cut it will assign everything to the more important payee. If it is not, it will prompt.
- When Merge Payee does prompt for merged payee name, clicking Cancel clears the payee name in payee list.

The merged payee name does initially appear in Payee Details > Details tab, but subsequently clicking on different payee, and then clicking the blank payee name (in payee list) results in blank fields under Payee Details > Details tab:
This will be fixed in the next release.
- Adding new Payee (via right-click) doesn't prompt to enter payee name ; it just creates one named "New Payee", "New Payee 1", etc
It will now auto-edit the new payee name.
- Creating new Payee also auto-creates Alias of "New Payee", "New Payee 1", etc, that must be deleted (if unwanted, which is likely always)
The aliases will now be updated if the payee name is changed initially.
- Deleting Payee via right-click does not offer confirmation prompt (Using Delete key DOES prompt for confirmation)
- Deleting Alias via right-click does not offer confirmation prompt (Using Delete key DOES prompt for confirmation)
I couldn't reproduce this. It should be prompting if you have transactions on the payee, and not if you don't.
- If Search box contains a search string, and a new payee is created that matches that entered search string, the new payee doesn't appear until search string is modified (to continue matching the new payee)
I'm not planning on changing this - the search is triggered by the change in the search box so it would be a lot of work to change this behaviour, and would need to be replicated across other datatypes.
- If a payee is selected in Payees list, and then same payee is clicked again, it highlights the name to allow editing ; while in that state, right-clicking the payee > Delete doesn't do anything
- Also (with payee name highlighted to be renamed), right-clicking the payee > Find All Transactions loads an empty list
These options are now disabled when the options are not available.
- While a payee is selected in Payees list, typing a letter doesn't shift focus to the first payee that starts with the typed letter ; this is VERY handy in MSMoney
Most of the grids should have a Search function at the top which I think works better if there are a lot of rows. But it's still a good suggestion so I have implemented this. I've also added it to the other grids.
maxim-money-dl97
Posts: 64
Joined: Wed 14 Oct, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by maxim-money-dl97 »

Am now on 1.14.2.0 and ran through the items ^^^ ; have these to report now :)

After merging payees, should Aliases have additional regex entry? The adding of this additional entry didn't appear consistent across pre-merged payees.
image.png
image.png (7.48 KiB) Viewed 2906 times
*Right after importing MSMoney .mny file, Undo doesn't appear to do anything after merging payees (even though hovering over the button reflects "Undo: Merge payees into [payee name] (Ctrl +Z)"

*Right after importing MSMoney .mny file, Undo for the regex alias (auto-addition) also appear not to do anything:
image.png
image.png (4.35 KiB) Viewed 2906 times
Right-clicking a payee (that has no transactions) > Find All Transactions loads an empty Search list ; instead of the empty list, can it prompt that no transactions exist for that payee?

(Unrelated, but I needed to re-import from MSMoney to retest the next item): When prompted for MSMoney's DB password, and it's entered incorrectly, rather than immediately cancelling the file-import process, can it re-prompt for correct password?

Right after importing from MSMoney, every payee in Payees list has grey text (as if they don't have any transactions, which isn't true), whereas prior to latest release, the ones with transactions were brighter white:
image.png
image.png (1.78 KiB) Viewed 2906 times
Note that quitting / restarting Maxim then reflects white-vs-grey payees like before.

(Also unrelated, but I saw this during this testing): Often-times trying to start Maxim will cause the .exe to appear in Task Mgr, but the app itself won't appear. Subsequently opening it again yields "Another instance of Maxim Money is already running..." What can be checked to determine why the app doesn't appear in first place?

(I submitted stack trace for this): After searching for payee(s), in the payee Name area, right-clicking to Add Payee causes Error / stack trace pop-up.

(Me)
Creating new Payee also auto-creates Alias of "New Payee", "New Payee 1", etc, that must be deleted (if unwanted, which is likely always)
(You}
The aliases will now be updated if the payee name is changed initially.
When adding a new payee, curious why Maxim still adds Alias that matches Payee name? Seems redundant, and payees imported from MSMoney don't get matching aliases added.

Can the alphabetization/sort setting be kept across app launches for Aliases? It reverts to being out of order after restarting Maxim.

When double-clicking on a payee in Payees box, can that load its transactions into Search box, rather than renaming the payee?

When a payee is highlighted in Payees box, can hitting F2 invoke the rename function (similar to File Explorer and Excel)?

This scenario doesn't yield "Unable to merge payees" when invoking Merge Payee action:
When a payee has Prevent Merging checked, and it's within the range of selected payees to be merged

(Me)
Deleting Payee via right-click does not offer confirmation prompt (Using Delete key DOES prompt for confirmation)
(You)
I couldn't reproduce this. It should be prompting if you have transactions on the payee, and not if you don't.
While retesting, when multi-selecting 2+ payees (with *no* transactions for all payees) and right-clicking to delete, it gives confirmation prompt.

(Me)
Deleting Alias via right-click does not offer confirmation prompt (Using Delete key DOES prompt for confirmation)
(You)
I couldn't reproduce this. It should be prompting if you have transactions on the payee, and not if you don't.
While retesting, hitting Del key on an alias, still DOES prompt for confirmation, whether payee has transactions or not.
While retesting, right-clicking to Delete Alias, does NOT prompt for confirmation, whether payee has transactions or not.
Campbell
Site Admin
Posts: 589
Joined: Sun 14 Jul, 2024 10:21 am
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by Campbell »

maxim-money-dl97 wrote: Thu 05 Nov, 2026 7:37 am After merging payees, should Aliases have additional regex entry? The adding of this additional entry didn't appear consistent across pre-merged payees.
Regexes are calculated when merging payees, and automatically added if they are long enough to be likely to be unique.
*Right after importing MSMoney .mny file, Undo doesn't appear to do anything after merging payees (even though hovering over the button reflects "Undo: Merge payees into [payee name] (Ctrl +Z)"

*Right after importing MSMoney .mny file, Undo for the regex alias (auto-addition) also appear not to do anything:
I think the undo is working here, it's just the alias grid is not refreshing immediately. I'm leaving this as-is just now.
Right-clicking a payee (that has no transactions) > Find All Transactions loads an empty Search list ; instead of the empty list, can it prompt that no transactions exist for that payee?
Done.
(Unrelated, but I needed to re-import from MSMoney to retest the next item): When prompted for MSMoney's DB password, and it's entered incorrectly, rather than immediately cancelling the file-import process, can it re-prompt for correct password?
It will now re-prompt an additional two times. After that it will behave like it does now (to discourage users from trying to brute force the password).
Right after importing from MSMoney, every payee in Payees list has grey text (as if they don't have any transactions, which isn't true), whereas prior to latest release, the ones with transactions were brighter white:
image.png
Note that quitting / restarting Maxim then reflects white-vs-grey payees like before.
I couldn't reproduce this one.
(Also unrelated, but I saw this during this testing): Often-times trying to start Maxim will cause the .exe to appear in Task Mgr, but the app itself won't appear. Subsequently opening it again yields "Another instance of Maxim Money is already running..." What can be checked to determine why the app doesn't appear in first place?
Were there any errors in the Windows event log? Or the maxim money log (should be in C:\Users\Yourname\AppData\Local\MaximMoney\logs)
(I submitted stack trace for this): After searching for payee(s), in the payee Name area, right-clicking to Add Payee causes Error / stack trace pop-up.
This is fixed in the next release.
When adding a new payee, curious why Maxim still adds Alias that matches Payee name? Seems redundant, and payees imported from MSMoney don't get matching aliases added.
It's a good point, I have removed the redundant aliases.
Can the alphabetization/sort setting be kept across app launches for Aliases? It reverts to being out of order after restarting Maxim.
I have sorted this list alphabetically.
When double-clicking on a payee in Payees box, can that load its transactions into Search box, rather than renaming the payee?
Done.
When a payee is highlighted in Payees box, can hitting F2 invoke the rename function (similar to File Explorer and Excel)?
Done.
This scenario doesn't yield "Unable to merge payees" when invoking Merge Payee action:
When a payee has Prevent Merging checked, and it's within the range of selected payees to be merged
I couldn't reproduce this, it always prevents the merge for me.
While retesting, when multi-selecting 2+ payees (with *no* transactions for all payees) and right-clicking to delete, it gives confirmation prompt.
Ah yes, if there are multiple payees it will also prompt.
While retesting, hitting Del key on an alias, still DOES prompt for confirmation, whether payee has transactions or not.
While retesting, right-clicking to Delete Alias, does NOT prompt for confirmation, whether payee has transactions or not.
Del key should now behave the same as Delete from the menu.
🔥 1
maxim-money-dl97
Posts: 64
Joined: Wed 14 Oct, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by maxim-money-dl97 »

...Often-times trying to start Maxim will cause the .exe to appear in Task Mgr, but the app itself won't appear. Subsequently opening it again yields "Another instance of Maxim Money is already running..." What can be checked to determine why the app doesn't appear in first place?
Found what's happening - this Error was waiting to be clicked, but was hidden somehow:
image.png
image.png (39.38 KiB) Viewed 2830 times
Thoughts?

(Me)
While retesting, hitting Del key on an alias, still DOES prompt for confirmation, whether payee has transactions or not.
While retesting, right-clicking to Delete Alias, does NOT prompt for confirmation, whether payee has transactions or not.
(You)
Del key should now behave the same as Delete from the menu.
So now it doesn't prompt confirmation when deleting an Alias via Del key or right-click (with or without existing transactions).
Campbell
Site Admin
Posts: 589
Joined: Sun 14 Jul, 2024 10:21 am
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by Campbell »

maxim-money-dl97 wrote: Fri 06 Nov, 2026 6:37 am Thoughts?
The integrity check is the first thing to run when opening a file. If you're launching Maxim Money directly from the data file, it's understandable that the dialog box would display before the form loads. Hopefully we can resolve the issue and prevent it appearing altogether.
So now it doesn't prompt confirmation when deleting an Alias via Del key or right-click (with or without existing transactions).
Yes, if it's a single alias. My thought was that deleting a single alias is not a significant action and an "Are you sure" dialog would be more annoying than useful, especially given it's covered by Undo. Do you disagree?
maxim-money-dl97
Posts: 64
Joined: Wed 14 Oct, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by maxim-money-dl97 »

The integrity check is the first thing to run when opening a file. If you're launching Maxim Money directly from the data file, it's understandable that the dialog box would display before the form loads. Hopefully we can resolve the issue and prevent it appearing altogether.
I actually start Maxim via shortcut, with "Reload last-used file on startup" enabled. Should I try a different app-start method?
So now it doesn't prompt confirmation when deleting an Alias via Del key or right-click (with or without existing transactions).
Yes, if it's a single alias. My thought was that deleting a single alias is not a significant action and an "Are you sure" dialog would be more annoying than useful, especially given it's covered by Undo. Do you disagree?
I can see your argument, and having the option to undo would make this one moot :)
Campbell
Site Admin
Posts: 589
Joined: Sun 14 Jul, 2024 10:21 am
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by Campbell »

The way you are starting is fine. Are you saving the data file after fixing it though?
maxim-money-dl97
Posts: 64
Joined: Wed 14 Oct, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Import from MS Money - Payee/variation issue

Post by maxim-money-dl97 »

Yes I've been saving the file more often - think this thread is good for now, appreciate all the attention (and user views lol!)
👍 1
Post Reply