Page 1 of 1

Product comparison - QIF import

Posted: Thu 07 Nov, 2024 7:56 pm
by Campbell
I've just done a quick comparison between a few finance applications, using a large QIF extract from MS Money. The fact that the majority of these applications cannot import the data correctly is quite shocking:

These are the final balances reported in each application:
  • BankTree: 3,062.13 - BankTree was extremely slow to import vs all the rest. It also ignores the opening amount.
  • GnuCash: 7,264.40 - GnuCash ignores the master line on split transactions and sums the underlying splits, ignoring any unassigned values
  • HomeBank: 1,070,311.31 - HomeBank completely ignores multiple transactions for the same amount on the same date!
  • Microsoft Money: 2,965.42
  • Money Manager Ex: 35,033.42 - Money Manager Ex seems to just ignore transactions without a payee specified
  • Moneydance: 2,965.42
  • More Money: 2,965.42

Re: Product comparison - QIF import

Posted: Fri 08 Nov, 2024 6:48 pm
by Amazone
I have tried several and never was able to import anything.
More Money is the only one that works for me.